Accessibility Help

British Broadcasting Corporation

BBC News Updated every minute of every day
News Front Page Africa Americas Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East South Asia UK Business Health Science & Environment Technology Entertainment Also in the news ----------------- Video and Audio ----------------- Programmes Have Your Say In Pictures Country Profiles Special Reports

Related BBC sites

Languages

Page last updated at 12:39 GMT, Friday, 6 November 2009
E-mail this to a friend
Printable version

Doubts renewed over Iran aims


Iranian long-range Shahab-3 missile before testing 28 September 2009 Iran has been developing and and testing long and short range missiles

The Guardian newspaper in the UK has reported that there is evidence Iran may have experimented with a highly advanced nuclear warhead design, prompting the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) to ask Tehran for an explanation.

BBC Diplomatic correspondent Jonathan Marcus assesses the revelations.

This report derives from a broader dossier, or working document, compiled by the IAEA's Safeguards Department, which explores various potential military aspects of Iran's nuclear programme.

This dossier has led to various questions being put to the Iranians which, so far, appear to have had no satisfactory answer.

The specific issue raised in this latest report focuses on the means of initiating a nuclear chain reaction using a highly sophisticated arrangement of high explosives.

This "two-point implosion device", as it is known, is significant because it would allow for the production of a much smaller and less cumbersome nuclear warhead - one that experts believe could easily fit onto Iran's existing Shahab 3 missiles.

Western divisions

Iran's reported failure to respond to the IAEA concerns inevitably raises all sorts of questions about its long-term nuclear ambitions.

It also highlights a fundamental division between western intelligence agencies.



A satellite image of what analysts believe is the facility at Qom
(External) Excerpts: IAEA Safeguards dossier Q&A: Iran and the nuclear issue Iran's arsenal of missiles

The US decided two years ago that while Iran had conducted research on a nuclear bomb, that work was probably halted in 2003. British and French intelligence agencies are thought to be far more sceptical that this programme was ever terminated.

There has been a long-running debate within the IAEA about just how far its suspicions about Iran's potential nuclear activities should be publicised and acted upon.

There were initially internal concerns about the potential authenticity of some of the material and also a reluctance at the highest levels to take steps that might damage progress with Iran on other fronts.

The climate, though, is changing.

In a recent safeguards report the IAEA noted that "the information contained in the documentation appears to have been derived from multiple sources over different periods of time, appears to be generally consistent, and is sufficiently comprehensive and detailed that it needs to be addressed by Iran with a view to removing the doubts which naturally arise."

Troubled talks

These reports about Iran's potential military research work come just as the latest efforts to negotiate a deal with Tehran are running into trouble.



Iran's response has been so miserable that it is hard to be optimistic
Mark Fitzfaptrick
IISS

A confidence-building proposal under which Iran would export low-enriched uranium from its stocks and in return would get fabricated fuel for a medical research reactor seems to have been rejected by the Iranians, at least in its present form.

"Iran's response has been so miserable that it is hard to be optimistic that this will go anywhere," says Mark Fitzpatrick, a proliferation expert at the International Institute of Strategic Studies (IISS), a London based think-tank.

The key thing about this proposal, he said, was that it would have set "an important precedent".

Some had even hoped that this might be the answer to constraining Iran's wider enrichment effort and in return providing fuel for its Russian-supplied power generating reactor.

Hopes are not exhausted but there are growing concerns in Western capitals that either Iran is seeking to drag out the talks or that political differences in Tehran simply mean that it is unable to respond in a definitive fashion.

Other experts though take a different view, though, wondering if the decades of mistrust between Iran and the West now require a greater understanding of Tehran's position.

It is clear, though, that if the current efforts to negotiate with Iran fail, then there will be ever-stronger scrutiny of Iran's past research activities.

The pendulum will also inevitably swing back to talk of tougher economic sanctions and renewed worries about possible Israeli military action against Iran.



Bookmark with:

What are these?


E-mail this to a friend
Printable version

Print Sponsor



IRAN NUCLEAR CRISIS KEY STORIES Iran urged over enrichment plan Iran 'to accept UN nuclear deal' Turkey chastises the West on Iran UN team 'sees Iran nuclear site' ANALYSIS AND BACKGROUND

Iranian nuclear scientists Q&A: Iran nuclear
BBC News examines the escalation of the crisis over Iran's nuclear programme
West mulls Iran 'change of heart' Talks herald new phase for Iran Iran voices: The nuclear crisis UN sanctions against Iran Iran's arsenal of missiles Nuclear power in the Middle East Iran's key nuclear sites CLICKABLE GUIDES Guide to the nuclear fuel cycle Guide: How Iran is ruled BBC WORLD SERVICE BBC Persian.com
RELATED INTERNET LINKS (External) IAEA The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
TOP MIDDLE EAST STORIES UK Iraq war inquiry to begin
Belgian admits Iran arms charges
Hamas 'debating Shalit swap deal'

MOST POPULAR STORIES NOW

Most popular now, in detail Most popular now, in detail Most popular now, in detail

FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS

Protest in Pakistan Paralysed state
Ahmed Rashid on conspiracy theories sweeping Pakistan

Red deer stag (S. Rowley) Wild city
Photographer goes on the trail of urban deer populations

men drinking sorghum beer bought from women sellers at Kauda market The next Darfur?
Region which could become new Sudan front line
Most Popular Now

Most Popular Now | 50,757 people are reading stories on the site right now.


Skip to top

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Quantcast

Explore the BBC

Home

Popular links

BBC links A to F

  1. BBC iPlayer
  2. CBBC
  3. CBeebies
  4. Food

BBC links H to L

  1. Health
  2. History
  3. Learning
  4. Local & Nations

BBC links M to Sc

  1. Music
  2. News
  3. Radio
  4. Science & Nature

BBC links Sp to W

  1. Sport
  2. TV
  3. Weather

A whole lot more

To top

Site Links

BBC links

BBC © MMIX

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.
Americas  Africa  Europe  Middle East  South Asia  Asia Pacific 

watch One-Minute World News

Change Text Only Settings

Graphic version of this page