Accessibility Help

British Broadcasting Corporation

BBC News Updated every minute of every day
News Front Page Africa Americas Asia-Pacific Europe Middle East South Asia UK Business Health Science & Environment Technology Entertainment Also in the news ----------------- Video and Audio ----------------- Programmes Have Your Say In Pictures Country Profiles Special Reports

Related BBC sites

Languages

Page last updated at 10:45 GMT, Thursday, 5 November 2009
E-mail this to a friend
Printable version

Iran: Too divided for nuclear deal?


Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei Khamenei could approve the deal but comments have not been conciliatory

By Roger Hardy
BBC Middle East analyst

As international pressure mounts on Iran over its nuclear programme, there are signs that political divisions are hampering its ability to make a deal.

The mood music is not very upbeat.

Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has said the country will not be dictated to - and there can be no dialogue if the United States is the wolf and Iran is the sheep.

The US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has warned the Iranians not to use delaying tactics. They must accept the deal put forward in October, she declared, adding that it would not be changed.

Under the deal, Iran would send its low-enriched uranium to Russia for further processing. This is seen as a necessary confidence-building measure.

Iranian officials initially favoured the proposal, but then seem to have had second thoughts.

Political football

So why is Iran blowing hot and cold?

Reading the opaque currents of Iranian politics is never easy.

Those, not least in Washington, who have mistrusted Iran all along have been quick to accuse it of negotiating in bad faith.



Bushehr nuclear power plant, Iran (file image)
Q&A: Iran and the nuclear issue Hopes raised for Iran agreement

But an alternative explanation is that the regime has been taken aback by the strength of criticism the proposed deal has aroused at home.

The issue has become a political football.

President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad badly needs to boost his legitimacy, after winning a second term in elections in June which many Iranians believe were rigged.

One way to do this is to claim victory over the West on the nuclear issue.

But, equally, his opponents - on both wings of the political spectrum - want to use the issue to weaken him.

Mir Hossein Mousavi, the president's principal rival in the elections and now the leader of the main opposition movement, has warned against any deal being struck at the opposition's expense.

Criticism has come from the conservative camp, too, with accusations that the president has caved in to Western pressure.

The heat of the debate seems to have rattled the regime.

Should it accept the deal, reject it or - despite Mrs Clinton's warning - try to renegotiate it?

Squabbling factions

The man who must decide is the Supreme Leader.

If he were to approve the deal, that would probably silence the squabbling factions.

The logic of this approach is clear.

At a time when the regime is under severe pressure both at home and abroad, a deal would defuse the pressure coming from the West - and stave off the prospect of further sanctions.

But the Leader's latest statement is scarcely conciliatory.

His remark about the sheep and the wolf is a quotation from the father of the Islamic revolution, the late Ayatollah Khomeini.

The clear implication is that if you converse with a wolf it will devour you.

The Supreme Leader, like the president, has been personally damaged by the crisis of legitimacy of the past five months - the most serious in the 30-year life of the Islamic Republic.

This might make him especially sensitive to the charge that he is making concessions to the West.

The outcome remains unclear. But it is possible that Iran's internal divisions are now so acute that it is unable to achieve a consensus on an issue of such magnitude.



Bookmark with:

What are these?


E-mail this to a friend
Printable version

Print Sponsor



IRAN NUCLEAR CRISIS KEY STORIES Iran urged over enrichment plan Iran 'to accept UN nuclear deal' Turkey chastises the West on Iran UN team 'sees Iran nuclear site' ANALYSIS AND BACKGROUND

Iranian nuclear scientists Q&A: Iran nuclear
BBC News examines the escalation of the crisis over Iran's nuclear programme
West mulls Iran 'change of heart' Talks herald new phase for Iran Iran voices: The nuclear crisis UN sanctions against Iran Iran's arsenal of missiles Nuclear power in the Middle East Iran's key nuclear sites CLICKABLE GUIDES Guide to the nuclear fuel cycle Guide: How Iran is ruled BBC WORLD SERVICE BBC Persian.com
TOP MIDDLE EAST STORIES Inquiry focuses on Iraq 'threat'
Four die in Israel 'copter crash
Gaddafi 'to mediate' football row

MOST POPULAR STORIES NOW

Most popular now, in detail Most popular now, in detail Most popular now, in detail

FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS

Chimneys silhouetted against the sun Warming globe
The past, present and possible future of climate change

Soldiers carrying one of the victims Clan rivalries
Tensions behind the Philippines political massacre

Muslim women in Berlin - file pic Hewitt on Europe
Europeans target immigrant ghettos in 'values' drive
Most Popular Now

Most Popular Now | 68,057 people are reading stories on the site right now.


Skip to top

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Quantcast

Explore the BBC

Home

Popular links

BBC links A to F

  1. BBC iPlayer
  2. CBBC
  3. CBeebies
  4. Food

BBC links H to L

  1. Health
  2. History
  3. Learning
  4. Local & Nations

BBC links M to Sc

  1. Music
  2. News
  3. Radio
  4. Science & Nature

BBC links Sp to W

  1. Sport
  2. TV
  3. Weather

A whole lot more

To top

Site Links

BBC links

BBC © MMIX

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.
Americas  Africa  Europe  Middle East  South Asia  Asia Pacific 

watch One-Minute World News

Change Text Only Settings

Graphic version of this page